Should I Replace My Water Heater Before It Fails?

Maybe your water heater still works, but if it’s getting old, you would be wise to start looking for a replacement. Keep in mind that, like all mechanical equipment, water heaters have a life expectancy. In this case, traditional storage water heaters last about 10 to 15 years, while tankless models can last 20 years or more.

Is it time to replace your water heater? This information should help you decide.

4 Reasons to Replace Your Water Heater Before It Fails

If you have a tight budget, you might be reluctant to replace your water heater before it fails completely. However, the simple fact is that all water heaters stop working eventually. While you want to get the longest service life for your money, waiting until the appliance breaks down may not be worth the hassle.

Here’s why a preemptive replacement could be beneficial:

  1. A broken water heater forces you to make a quick decision: When your water heater dies, you don’t have time to research the difference between standard tanks and tankless models. You can’t weigh the pros and cons of natural gas vs. electric units, or explore the possibility of a heat pump water heater. Without time to think over all your options, you may not make the best decision.
  2. A broken water heater leaves you without hot water: In an emergency water heater replacement, you won’t have hot water until the new unit can be delivered and installed. This could make life miserable for you and your family for a couple of days. On the other hand, a planned and scheduled water heater replacement is quick, convenient, and performed on your schedule.
  3. A corroded water heater could cause significant damage: All water heaters come with a sacrificial anode rod. This small piece of steel is surrounded by aluminum, magnesium, or zinc to attract corroding compounds in the water and protect the tank from rusting. Unless you replace this rod every few years, your water heater could begin taking a beating. If the tank rusts through, it could fail catastrophically and flood your home. You can avoid this disaster by replacing your water heater before it fails.
  4. A new water heater could lower your utility bills: You must invest in a new water heater, but it will start paying your back immediately in lower energy bills. Since water heating costs are second only to space heating and cooling costs, your return on investment could occur quite quickly.

5 Signs that Your Water Heater is Failing

You may intend to put off replacing your water heater for as long as possible, but don’t delay having the appliance serviced if you notice any of these signs of a failing water heater:

  1. Lack of hot water
  2. Strange noises coming from the water heater
  3. Red or brown water coming from the tap
  4. Visible rust on the water heater tank
  5. Puddles forming around the water heater

Contact Us for More Information About Water Heaters

If your water heater is showing signs of failure, the first step is to schedule water heater repair. This can reveal if your water heater has more life left in it, or if replacing it is the more cost-effective choice.

The expert plumbers at Blind & Sons can offer advice on which replacement water heater meets your family’s needs and budget best. Then, whether you decide to replace your water heater today or a year from now, you’ll know where to turn!

Choose Blind & Sons for water heater repair or replacement in Northeast Ohio. You can schedule service online or call (330) 753-7711 today.

We proudly offer 24/7 emergency plumbing service!

Schedule Service


“The team of R.T., S.M and N.B did an amazing job. They literally worked their butts off, and their attention to detail was truly above the bar. I will...” Jim. F.
“For the very positive, service person (A.G.) was excellent: locating the exact location of the plumbing leak within an upstairs bathroom wall, cutting...” J. M.
“These folks stay true to this day. From being easy work with, their professionalism to the quality of work that is put in. Blind & Sons will remai...” Corey A.
Why Choose
Blind & Sons?
24/7 HVAC & Plumbing Emergency Service
Satisfaction Guarantee
Schedule Service Online
Referral Club
MVP Program Savings
Get cozy with extra savings
Get a High-Efficiency Furnace with $1,500 off and 36 mo. no interest!* 10 Years Parts & Labor
Expires 01/31/2022
Get $2,000 OFF* off Any Generator! Special Financing Available.
Expires 01/31/2022
ONLY $29* Replace any Switch or Outlet!
Expires 01/31/2022
ONLY $69** Furnace Tune-Up
Expires 01/31/2022
Smart Home Energy Management Offer
Expires 01/31/2022
$100 OFF* Duct Cleaning!
Expires 01/31/2022
FREE* Plumbing or Electric Service Call with Repair
Expires 01/31/2022
Serving Our
Northeast Ohio
We are committed to bringing our
community fast, affordable home
comfort solutions.